South Carolina executes death row inmate despite pleas from jurors and a judge to spare his life

South Carolina carried out the execution of Richard Moore on Friday evening, according to the state, a day after the US Supreme Court declined the Black inmate’s request to halt his lethal injection over his claim prosecutors unjustly excluded Black people from the all-White jury that convicted him.

Moore, a 59-year-old convicted of killing a convenience store clerk 25 years ago, was pronounced dead at 6:24 p.m., said Chrysti Shain, spokesperson for the South Carolina Department of Corrections, at a news conference Friday evening.

Moore had also requested clemency from Gov. Henry McMaster, but the governor denied the request Friday, allowing the execution to proceed as scheduled. Two years ago, in discussing Moore’s case, the Republican governor said he would not issue a commutation.

More than 20 people – including two jurors, the judge from Moore’s original trial and a former director of the state prison system – had asked McMaster to spare Moore’s life by granting him clemency, The Associated Press reported.

“This is definitely a part of my life I wish I could change because I took a life, you know? I took someone’s life,” Moore says in a video released by his attorneys as part of his clemency request.

Moore was the last person remaining on South Carolina’s death row to be convicted by a jury with no Black members, his defense attorneys say. He is the second person put to death since the state resumed capital punishment following a 13-year pause prompted by difficulty obtaining drugs for its lethal injection protocol, an issue other states have faced.

Moore was convicted of killing a White convenience store clerk, James Mahoney, during a 1999 robbery. Moore entered the store in Spartanburg County unarmed and pulled Mahoney’s handgun away from him. Mahoney then grabbed a second gun and shot Moore in the arm before Moore fired a fatal shot at Mahoney, prosecutors asserted.

Moore fled, taking a bag filled with more than $1,400 cash, they said.

Moore had asserted to the nation’s high court prosecutors impermissibly struck two Black jurors because of their race in his 2001 murder case, which the state denied. South Carolina officials argued Moore had already raised similar claims and lost, while also noting one of his jurors was Hispanic. The Supreme Court denied his request Thursday without comment, and there were no noted dissents.

Defense attorneys also have argued Moore killed Mahoney in self-defense. “No other South Carolina death penalty case has involved an unarmed defendant who defended himself when the victim threatened him with a weapon,” they said in a statement.

Moore’s son, who was 4 years old when his father was charged, says his father deserves mercy.

“He’s a human being who made mistakes,” Lyndall Moore told the AP. “And this particular mistake led to the death of another human being. But his sentence is completely disproportionate to the actual crime.”

At the news conference, Shain shared Moore’s final statement before he was put to death, which his attorney read aloud at the execution. “To the family of Mr. James Mahoney, I am deeply sorry for the pain and sorrow I caused you,” Moore’s statement said.

“To my children and granddaughters, I love you and I am so proud of you. Thank you for the joy you have brought to my life. To all of my family and friends, new and old, thank you for your love and support,” the statement said.

Two days before Moore’s execution, McMaster said he was looking into Moore’s clemency request. “The death penalty is a very serious decision regardless of the circumstances,” McMaster said Wednesday. “That’s a very permanent, very serious, awesome punishment, and it must be considered very, very carefully.”

McMaster told a reporter in 2022 of Moore’s case: “I have no intention to commute a sentence. The jury made their decision.”

The Supreme Court in 1986 ruled prosecutors cannot strike a potential juror based solely on race. If challenged, the state must state a “race-neutral” reason for excluding the candidate.

In Moore’s case, prosecutor Trey Gowdy – who later served four terms as a Republican congressman – told the judge the primary reason one Black jury candidate was struck was because she had tried to hide her criminal record during questioning, while he chose to exclude another because that person’s son had been convicted of murder, the state wrote in opposing Moore’s Supreme Court request.

A White jury candidate who also had a close family member prosecuted for murder had also been stricken for the same reason, Gowdy told the judge at the time. Moore’s counsel did not raise any challenges with Gowdy’s stated reasons at the time when asked by the trial court, according to the state.

In a brief filed Tuesday with the Supreme Court, the South Carolina attorney general argued it was too late for Moore to raise the issue of jurors’ race because it had not been mentioned in some earlier appeals. Moore’s attorneys responded Wednesday the case’s “unique procedural backdrop” should allow the justices to consider their arguments.

CNN reached out to Gowdy for comment Thursday. The GOP state attorney general’s and governor’s offices have not responded to CNN’s request for comment on Moore’s petition to the nation’s high court.

Moore was convicted of murder and armed robbery, among other charges, following two hours of deliberation by the jury, which sentenced him to death after only one more hour of discussion, the Spartanburg Herald-Journal reported in 2001.

Moore has chosen to be executed by lethal injection, his attorneys say, after wrangling over South Carolina’s access to lethal injection drugs led McMaster to sign a law in 2021 allowing the state to also execute by electrocution or firing squad, with death row inmates given the choice.

More than 1,600 people have been executed in the US since the Supreme Court reinstated the death penalty in 1976, according to the Death Penalty Information Center. Thirty-four percent have been Black, more than double the proportion of Black US residents in 2023.

As to the clemency petition, McMaster intended “to review everything that I can in a timely fashion,” the governor told reporters Wednesday.

In an earlier federal court request for a stay of execution, Moore’s attorneys expressed concern about McMaster’s past comments regarding clemency for death sentences, the ruling denying that request shows.

The statement, Moore’s attorneys had argued, shows McMaster could not make a fair decision on a clemency request because he “would have to renounce years of his own work” in support of the death penalty as the state’s attorney general.

McMaster told the court in response: “It is and has been my intention and commitment to take care to understand the issues presented, including those from my review and consideration of applications, petitions, and requests for clemency presented to me by or on behalf of a condemned inmate … .”